Is it OK for a Christian to marry someone who is agnostic? | Questions & Answers
Christian agnostics practice a distinct form of agnosticism that applies only to the properties of Christ: Weatherhead believed in the divinity of Christ, in that he ( Jesus) stood in a special relationship with God and "indeed an incarnation of God. Though my judgments of Christianity and belief have evolved to a more And for those who have ever been in a long, committed relationship. I would think the struggles tend to be toward the differences between the two and their beliefs, which depending on how strong the beliefs are, probably will alter.
Some couples with different worldviews go out of their way to avoid the topic. But if the rest are any indication, including many of my survey respondents, they might be missing out on a good thing. One respondent after another described having deeper conversations with their partners and learning more about each other in the process than they ever did in their shared-belief relationships.
When you have the same belief, you assume a lot without asking. My husband is the only person I have entrusted with my nonbelief, and he has been kind and considerate and loving in a way that I know not even my closest friends or family members would be. And through it all we have realized that our relationship is built on a strong foundation. But living with someone whose beliefs are different—especially someone on the far side of the chasm between the natural and supernatural—makes a person more likely to think deeply and well about what he or she believes.
I know I thought much more deeply and intensely about my own beliefs when Becca was still religious, even though we only rarely engaged the questions. Just the presence of the difference was like a whetstone against which I sharpened my mind. I have joined Meetups and groups both secular and religious I would have otherwise never gone to and met some wonderful people.
My life is richer and more meaningful as a result of this. His questions have helped me look deeper into my faith practices. Since the birth of my daughters, I have had to take a much closer look at my own worldview in order to be able to explain it to them in terms they can understand and in a way that will not offend my partner.
He described himself as "agnostic Christian". Mexican actor and director, claims to be "culturally Catholic" and "spiritually agnostic". Spanish surrealist painter born in Figueres, Spain. He allegedly claimed to be both an agnostic and a Roman Catholic. British-born American theoretical physicist and mathematician, famous for his work in quantum electrodynamics, solid-state physics, astronomy and nuclear engineering. He describes himself as "a practicing Christian but not a believing Christian".
Hungarian-American mathematician and polymath who made major contributions to a vast number of fields, including set theory, functional analysis, quantum mechanics, ergodic theory, geometry, fluid dynamics, economics, linear programming, game theory, computer science, numerical analysis, hydrodynamics, and statistics, as well as many other mathematical fields. It is indicated that he was an "agnostic Catholic" due to his agreement with Pascal's Wager.
Along with David J. While he now considers himself agnostic, he still has a fondness for the Church. While we try not to be totally relativistic, our beliefs can coexist comfortably - His family and my family are okay with this arrangement.
His parents don't mind and neither do mine. I think it's harder for my bf to see the "No, there's no hole in my life, I've just never seen a need to insert a higher power into it" perspective. He's a great guy though, so he's getting his head around it. The only real trouble we've had is when his friendly family minister tried to foist a book of psalms for "interfaith couples" on us and I [privately] rejected her gift as wholly inappropriate to my non-faith lifestyle and my bf took offense when I [privately] called it "sales and marketing for Jesus.
The upshot is that since religion doesn't figure largely in either of our lives compared to, say, politics, rural living, or the proper way to treat animals, I'm comfortable with it being an area of mild disagreement. Eventually the kids decide on their own. On the other side of the coin, I think it also helped that Dad didn't try to actively push his worldview either.
He'd talk about it if we asked. Many people wind up getting more serious about their belief system when that happens. You are right to be concerned with this. Even if the two of you are amicable about the difference, when your theoretical offspring start asking Those Kinds of Questions things can get interesting.
- The Seven Benefits of a Relationship Between an Atheist and a Believer
- Christian agnosticism
My general recommendation is that two people contemplating marriage really do need to be on the same page when it comes to things like faith or politics Anyway, on to the question. I'm an atheist, and my wife is a christian. We both try to respect each other's views - I believe this can be the key to success in ANY marriage The two of us have been married for 10 years, and we are absolutely crazy about each other.
Religious differences, to some degree, will occur in almost any situation. I think the two of us established that we would discuss our differences openly, and not avoid the topic in our household.
In my opinion, it's made a big difference in how we perceive the "other side of the fence," and has added to our respect of one another. We do have a son - he's four. We made the decision early on that his religious beliefs were entirely up to him.
On some days he decides to go to church with Mom, and then on others he stays home with me. If he decides to be a christian, I'm fine with it. If he decides to become an atheist like myself, more power to him. If he decides to dance with a pink bra on his head and sing the "My Little Pony" theme song while worshipping a large glowing rock in the middle of the Magic Sea, so be it. Not my choice - it's entirely his own.
It's worked out well so far - I still love her as much as the day I first met her - even more so.
I believe she kind of has a thing for me as well. It's that damn christian bitch's fault.
agnostic and christian relationship | Christian Forums
Cheers to you, and good luck. Not everyone whose faith is important to them is justlikeyou. It works in my marriage, but you both need to respect the other's beliefs beyond just paying lip service to it. Alternatively, if she deeply believes that you are going to hell, that's going to be uncomfortable, too.
If either of you fit in that category, it's going to be tough. My parents heaved a sigh of releif because they didn't have to go to church anymore. If you two have dated this long without conflict and it's been brought up several times, I wouldn't worry. I've seen mixed-faith couples, and how things work out really depends a lot on how mature you are about your kids. Find out ahead of time if your girlfriend would be open to teaching them both ways and demonstrating how faith is a personal thing.
In fact, I dated one for a while I thought she was amazing, she felt the same about me, but she ended up going back to her redneck high school boyfriend for the sole reason that she didn't want to end up like her mom and dad.
agnostic and christian relationship
We see the spiritual life as a journey, not an arrival, cue new age music so we continually evolve our beliefs as a response to our experiences and our dialogue with each other. From this perspective, it strikes me as odd to expect to believe the same thing another person does. I sense, though, that most of your concern isn't so much with what is believed as with what is named.
Most orthodoxy requires that we put our scattered and disperate beliefs into one tidy box or another: Baptist, or Catholic, or Athiest, etc.
Christian agnosticism - Wikipedia
As tempting as this may be, I recommend against it. My spiritual compas directs me to seek not the party of truth, but the truth. If you can tolerate her beliefs, then you can tolerate exposing the kids to her beliefs and letting them decide, right?
Religious philosophy aside, churchgoing doesn't have to be a bad thing. Can't you convert to agnosticism and meet her halfway? She doesn't believe in hell, for instance. Her view of god is more of a "benevolent creator" rather than one of "justice".
She does, however, want her children to grow up in the church.
I'm not entirely sure what "growing up in the church" entails. That's where i'm still at, with atheist tendencies. I want to raise my kids in a house where they choose their religious beliefs like you guys describe. She doesn't think i'm burning in hell as she doesn't believe in itbut she does think that i'm "misguided". It is odd how society works, isn't it? The most natural thing to do actually respect each other's intelligence and sincerityis the least practiced. She wants to raise the children in the church, not in a "you decide your religon" way.
I'm not really sure how i can compromise. If you don't believe in hell, then you're not worried about your spouse maybe going there, and if that's the case, marrying an atheist isn't such a scary proposition. I'm an agnostic with atheistic leanings, and married an agnostic with theistic leanings.
Our kids are heathens, on all levels. Interestingly, it's our parents with whom we have religious tensions. THEY believe in hell. And they don't mean to have their granddaughters burning in it. Have you thought that part out? It's easy to theorize about standing your ground and not doing things to please other people, but it's another thing entirely to actually be faced with a grandma who literally lies awake at night worrying that a lack of Sunday School is going to damn her grandkids to the fiery depths So, you might want to mull that over a bit.
I see your problem. She may not see her problem, which is that your beliefs or lack of them will influence the kids no matter what, just because of who you are. Would you go to church with them, btw? If not, they'll wonder why not. And even if you were both Bible thumpers, that doesn't mean the kids would be, necessarily. That's what I meant about them making up their own minds.
With 2 basically tolerant parents, they're going to come out fine. If your church is all hellfire and damnation, that might be the thing that turns them more to your way of thinking.
If the church is basically a cool place with nice people, then they'll do fine.